Sunday, 2 November 2014

Reflection on Week 12 Tutorial - Project Reflection

Week 12 was the final presentations for the Kopi Coffee design proposal. Considering it was all over, I reflected on what I had learnt from the project. As Glanville (2007) said, one should always consider the notion of leaving room for continuous improvement.

  1. Divergent thinking and convergent thinking should be used together to be most effective. If used individually, they will have no where near the effect as together. Engaging in divergent thinking first, then using convergent thinking to narrow down to a final solution will provide the best result.
  2. Project scoping is an essential step that must be completed early on. It helps clarify the objectives of the project, and gives a general plan to follow. Organisation is paramount when conducting a major project and a project scope will assist this.
  3. Branding is something that must be considered early on, but not forced. How a product or company is branded can be the difference between success and failure, but is ultimately up to the consumer to decide.
  4. Ethical guidelines must always be considered when undergoing a project. Although they are easy to forget or brush over, if forgotten, it could result in disaster. I learnt that I need to keep them in mind at all times, to avoid having to make changes later. 

References (APA)

Glanville, R. (2007). Designing Complexity. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 20(2), 75-96.

Wednesday, 29 October 2014

Reflection on Week 11 Tutorial - Project Evaluation

Project evaluation was the topic for week 11, and considering we were finishing our assignments, it was an appropriate and relevant matter to ponder on. The lecture pointed out some ethical guidelines to follow when undergoing a project. Zigmond (2011) pointed out the importance of ethical guidelines in a profession, saying that they must be kept 'alive, relevant and effective'. One of these ethical guidelines stood out to me; to 'design for all' - avoid the common pitfall of “designing for yourself; the world does not consist of only 20-25 year olds. Considering I was designing a coffee shop and I fall into that age category, this made me think. I considered the fact that maybe I had started designing the coffee shop for 'myself' - thinking of what a 20-25 year old requires and wants. Therefore, I decided to question some of my design choices and examining the premises behind them. After some tweaking and changes, I felt that my design followed the ethical guidelines more. I would never have known that I had violated the guidelines if it hadn't been pointed out to me, and this taught me to adhere to them more closely in the future.


References (APA)

Zigmond, M. J. (2011). Making Ethical Guidelines Matter. American Scientist, 99(4), 296-299.

Sunday, 19 October 2014

Reflection on Week 10 Tutorial - Project Scoping and Branding

For Week 10, we learnt about project scoping and completed one for our own assignment. Project scoping is incredibly important, as it sets the guidelines for the project and illuminates all the crucial bits of information. By completing my own project scope, I clarified the basic premises of the project, making my objectives clear.

We also focused on branding. Branding is a complex topic to explore, as a brand isn't created by the company, but by the consumers. It can be influenced, but ultimately is left to the consumers to create. Travis (2001) says that 'creating an emotional bond with buyers is essential'. As the Kopi Coffee shop assignment requires us to consider branding, it's important to keep this point in mind. Instead of trying to create a 'brand' straight off that people are forced to accept, it is wiser and more effective to influence people to create a desirable brand image for themselves. This could be done through the way the coffee shop operates, its advertising, pricing, and all sorts of other details. With all this in mind, I set about brainstorming ways to create a unique, Australian branding for my Kopi Coffee shop proposal.


References (APA)

Travis, D. (2001). BRANDING IN THE DIGITAL AGE. Journal Of Business Strategy, 22(3), 14-18. doi:10.1108/eb040166

Sunday, 12 October 2014

Reflection on Week 9 Tutorial - Creativity

After a week off to refresh, I entered week 9. We received our grades for Assessment 1, which I was very satisfied with. It demonstrated that the feedback I received paid off and helped me obtain a higher grade. Assessment 3 was briefly introduced to us, causing me to begin thinking about my ideas for the assignment. The lessons I learned from Assessment 1 can all be applied to Assessment 3 to help me gain a good mark.

Our topic for the lesson was divergent and convergent thinking. This was explored through some exercises. The first exercise consisted of the students forming into groups, and coming up with alternative uses for a fork. Obviously, the amount of uses the group could come up with was important - but also originality. I had no trouble thinking of multiple uses for a fork, and our group accumulated almost 30 uses before the time was up. However, upon sharing our responses with the class, I realised that my ideas weren't very original - I had engaged in convergent thinking. Instead of thinking of ideas that were 'outside the box', I generally came up with more obvious options. With this in mind, I moved on to the next exercise, hoping to be more creative.

The list of uses for a fork can be seen on the left page.
The next exercise was done alone, and followed a similar structure. We were given a specific shape - the beginning of a drawing - that we had to finish. This required an open mind, as the drawing didn't look like anything particular to begin with. I decided to actively try and free my mind for this exercise, desperately trying not to get stuck on one idea and fall into convergent thinking. I feel like I was able to succeed better in this exercise, with all my ideas being different to each other. I was engaging more in divergent thinking - the ability to produce multiple, unique responses to a single stimulus (Clark, Veldman & Thorpe, 1965).

The drawing exercise was easier for me

References (APA)

Clark, C., Veldman, D., & Thorpe, J. (1965). Convergent and divergent thinking abilities of talented adolescents. Journal Of Educational Psychology, 56(3), 157-163. doi:10.1037/h0022110

Sunday, 28 September 2014

Reflection on Week 7 Tutorial - Creative Process

For Week 7, our topic was the creative process. Considering our assignments were due at the end of this week, this topic was hugely relevant. The lecture presented a number of useful point to assist our creative process's. This included: knowledge diversity, reasoning by metaphor and analogy and curiosity playfulness. Foss (2007) acknowledged this last point, saying that 'there has to be passionate involvement in one's work, not just industriousness'.

The tutorial was our final chance to get some feedback on our assignments before submitting on Sunday. Therefore, I prepared a full draft copy for marking, complete with sketches and correct formatting. Raghu looked over it and gave me advice, which helped me greatly. I realised that the assignment isn't about how detailed and thought out the final concept is, but it is about the process and research that I did to get there. Both the topic for this week - the creative process - and Raghu's individual guidance with me helped me realise this. I needed to illustrate this more in my assignment and show my whole creative process. Overall, this week helped me greatly, and ultimately likely improved my grade. It illustrated just how important it is to get feedback on assessment items.


References (APA)

Foss, L. (2006). About The Creative Process. The Yale Review, 94(3), 115-122. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9736.2006.00214.x

Sunday, 21 September 2014

Reflection on Week 6 Tutorial - Ideation

For this week we looked at ideation, and how to come up with creative ideas and solutions. A good ideation process will produce a solution that is novel, original and of value. Briggs (2010) says that the goal of ideation is not to necessarily come up with a large quantity of ideas, but to come up with quality ideas. We were taught to put effort into preparation and research, and not to fall in love with early designs. This is something I know I can struggle with - all to often, I will come up with an idea straightaway and go with that. Instead, it is better to continue the process and to allow new ideas to formulate, as they will potentially be better solutions.

Week 6 was the crucial period in which to get work done on my assignment. Being due in week 7, this was the time when the crux of the work must be done. I felt that the ideation process applied strongly to the assignment, which requires us to go through a design process and arrive at a final solution. In the tutorial, we discussed with classmates about our ideas. This opened up my mind to more possibilities, and reiterated the fact that I should avoid getting bogged down on the same idea. It is all too easy to stick with an idea you love, even if its the first one you came up with. Learning more about the ideation process taught me that I should not just use my first concept, but develop them further.


References (APA)

Briggs, R. O., & Reinig, B. A. (2010). Bounded Ideation Theory. Journal Of Management Information Systems, 27(1), 123-144.

Monday, 15 September 2014

Reflection on Week 5 Tutorial - Design Methods

During the break between week 4 and 5, we were set the task of conducting some research for our upcoming assignment. I decided to interview a number of people who fit in the target audience of the assignment (18-25 year olds) and find out their answers to some questions about saving money for retirement. The answers I got were interesting, and slightly alarming. Almost all of the people I interviewed had not even thought about saving money for their retirement, and many of them weren't even interested in doing so after proposing the idea to them. I brought this research to the tutorial and compared with the findings of others. Unsurprisingly, many of my classmates had similar results from their findings. From sharing around all of our preliminary research, I was able to gain a more refined problem statement. This exercise taught me that research must always be done first in order to identify where the root of the problem lies. Simply looking at the task and assuming what the problem will be is not adequate. Also, research can potentially discount or discredit previous assumptions.

This idea of conducting preliminary research in order to identify the problem should apply to just about every profession and even to daily life (Nagurney, 2007). For example, in the field of media production, if I was tasked with a challenging movie to shoot I would apply this process. Rather than trying to guess where problems or challenges may lie, some research into the task and what it involves will help greatly with identifying issues that need addressing. This is especially important considering that shooting a movie is not cheap, and every minute spent wasted adds to the cost of the project! Therefore, by doing your research first, there should be minimal time wasted once the production of the film begins.


References (APA)

Nagurney, A. (2007). The Importance of Research. Chronicle Of Higher Education, 53(22), B18.

Saturday, 6 September 2014

Reflection on Week 4 Tutorial - Design Problem

Week 4 was full of surprises for me, and turned out to be a real eye opener. In our preparation for the tutorial, we watched a lecture which included the question: how would one redesign a watch? Initially, I thought this wasn't too hard - simply find flaws with the watch, and redesign them. However, this turned out to be the wrong way to approach the problem.

In the tutorial it was explained to us that instead of finding a new solution, we should reformulate the problem itself. I instantly thought to myself: what is the problem that the watch solves in the first place? The idea of reformulating the problem and not creating solutions was hard for me to grapple with at first - I suppose all these years of straight minded thinking where we follow the design process are hard to shake off. However, after a bit of time in our small groups, I started to gain a clear thought track. Instantly I found new ways of reformulating the problem and looking at the bigger picture, not just the design of the watch itself. I had to look further than refining the design of a product but reinterpret the problem instead. I've realised that this process opens the mind up to finding crazy, innovative and potentially brilliant ideas. It's so easy to get caught up in the mundane, and to simply add small tweaks to existing designs - this happens in the technology market constantly. However, constraints still exist when designing products. Constraints differ from requirements in that requirements must be satisfied, but constraints must not be violated (Wielinga & Schreiber, 1997). The next 'big thing' is waiting out there to be designed, it simply needs a person who can think outside the box and be innovative.

I feel that this last week has given me a step in the right direction to becoming a better and more innovative designer. For my chosen field - media production - this will help me greatly. When filming and editing a project, there is much thought that goes into the camera angles, shot types and editing styles. It's a form of design - and most movies follow the same basic principles and ideas. If someone can come up with a new, unexplored way to communicate a story through film, the potential for success could be limitless. This is where I want to head towards, I don't just want to always follow the beaten path and do everything the way those before me have. I want to be innovative and to create products that are distinctively my own, and this past week has helped me on my way to getting there.


References (APA)

Wielinga, B., & Schreiber, G. (1997). Configuration-design problem solving. IEEE Expert, 12(2), 49-56. doi:10.1109/64.585104

Sunday, 31 August 2014

Reflection on Week 3 Tutorial - Design, Designer, Designing

Week 3 brought about some interesting concepts and ideas. Our homework was to think about how we would take on the task of designing signage for a facility that hosts patients with dementia. My initial response was to look at the problem using the design process - what it the brief, what criteria do I have to work with, etc. However, after the tutorial I discovered that maybe this wasn't the best way for me to start - more on that later.

In our tutorial we were set a task of building a paper bridge. However, we were challenged to ignore the design process, and just do whatever comes to mind. This struck me as odd at first, as I'm so used to following a design process and going through it systematically. However, once I was able to let go of this, I found that ideas sprung to my head at breakneck pace. Rather than slowly working my way through a process, my mind was running wild and coming up with idea after idea of how to design the bridge. Together with my team, we brainstormed and threw ideas at one another, until we reached a mutual agreement on which design to build. Wilpert (2007) raised the notion that working in teams creates a 'social – or better collective, co-operative, organised and medially facilitated process', resulting in a better end product. Like a well oiled machine, we each set about our own task and worked together to construct the bridge and finished it in the nick of time. Although it wasn't quite what we originally envisioned in our heads, our design worked and this proved that ignoring the design process didn't impair our ability to complete the task.
Our bridge holding the 500g load.
 Although our method of throwing ideas at each other may have seemed unorganised and spontaneous, when we analysed it afterwards and thought about how our ideas came to fruition we realised it wasn't as chaotic as first perceived. I realised that I naturally sifted through ideas in my brain, dismissing silly ideas and running possible plans through their paces. I was able to subconsciously go through a rudimentary design process - this exercise really opened my eyes up to that fact. By just forgetting all the rules and letting my mind loose, I still managed to come up with a good design that worked.

This mind map we created illustrates our process during the construction of the bridge.


References (APA)

Wilpert, B. (2007). Psychology and design processes. Safety Science, 45(1-2), 293-303. doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2006.08.016


Sunday, 24 August 2014

Reflection on Week 2 Tutorial - Introduction

For Week 2 we were required to complete some homework from the online lecture (I discussed this in my week 1 blog post). I turned up to the tutorial with my homework ready and an open mind. Once we had done the formalities and found ourselves in small groups, I pitched my idea to the group - that cleaning your room is a design process. Together, we found many points where we could refer this process to the design process, and ended up pitching it to the class.

I realized a number of things from this exercise - humans design by nature, no matter what profession we decide to take on. It's simply in our psych and our way of solving everyday problems - once a problem is encountered, one must design a way to fix it. Wong (2011) said that design is a requirement, not a cosmetic addition. I thought about how this relates to my particular area of study (media production). Essentially, design is an integral part of media production. For example, filming a movie is a design activity - there is a brief received from a client, then the filmmaker must design and implement different concepts (storyboarding and scriptwriting) and then consult with the client to see which they like best. Then the filmmaker implements their chosen design by filming and editing, and finally produces a final product. This product meets a specific set of criteria set by th ace client, and if these must all be met.

By doing this homework exercise, I feel like I have gained a much better understanding of what designing is, and just how many designtivities there are in daily life. Furthermore, I realise that my future profession (media production) is centered around design - making an understanding of the design process all the more important.


References (APA)

Wong, B. (2011). Points of view: The design process. Nat Meth, 8(12), 987-987. doi:10.1038/nmeth.1783

Wednesday, 20 August 2014

Reflection on Week 1

Although there was no tutorial in week 1, we were tasked to watch a lecture and do some homework in preparation for week 2. The lecture discussed the course and the assessment items, which gave me some time to think and run a few ideas through my head for future assignments. However, the most interesting element was the homework task: to think of an everyday activity that could be called a design activity.

This got me thinking - what tasks do I do everyday that require cognitive thinking? What tasks follow the design process? Initially, I could only think of one idea - packing my bag for school. However, this didn't seem like the strongest argument I could think of, so I racked my brain and came up with a couple more for the tutorial in week 2. My final answer to our homework task is revealed in my blog entry for week 2!